Explore Collections
You are here:
CollectionsOnline
/
[108] Composite drawing with plans, elevation and perspectives of Picture Gallery, Mausoleum and almshouses, as built and as proposed but rejected, exhibited at the Royal Academy in 1823
Browse
Reference number
SM P265
Purpose
[108] Composite drawing with plans, elevation and perspectives of Picture Gallery, Mausoleum and almshouses, as built and as proposed but rejected, exhibited at the Royal Academy in 1823
Aspect
Top left: Angular view from the entrance court agreably to the original design - an ideal design built in stone with a two-storey entrance porch
Centre left: The Picture Gallery - as built except that the initial wall colour was burnt ochre
Bottom left: The plan of the building in its present unfinished and / altered state - as built except that it shows the abandoned free-standing arcade on the east front; 'unfinished and altered' refers to the omission of the east porch
Top centre: View of the entrance front in its present unfinished state - in fact, as built except that the south door (built 1815-16) is omitted
Centre: Central view from the entrance court agreably to the original design - related to the 'Top left design'
Bottom centre: View of the lawn front of the building with the omission of the temporary entrance at the south east corner - as built except for the omission of the 'temporary' south door that was there until 1939
Centre right: The Mausoleum - as built
Bottom right: The plan of the / buildings agreably to the / original design - with the unbuilt east porch, arcade and quadrangle
Inscribed
(on frame) Mausoleum and Picture Gallery with God's Gift College, Dulwich (Sir John Soane, 1811)
(title, top right) Dulwich College. The Picture / Gallery and the Mausoleum erected pursuant to the Will and at the expense of the late Sir Francis Bourgeois / This assemblage has been made to illustrate the doctrine of the Rev. T. F. Dibdin lately / promulgated respecting the advantages to the Public of liberal criticism and the unshackled freedom / of the Press
The Picture Gallery (twice), the masters / and / fellows / apartment, library, chapel, Mausoleum
Signed and dated
- datable to 1823?
Medium and dimensions
Pen and coloured washes, watercolour technique, shaded within gilt frame (900 x 1460)
Hand
Joseph Michael Gandy (1771-1843)
Watermark
not visible
Notes
This drawing was exhibited at the Royal Academy in 1823 (RA No. 1056). At exhibition it was titled 'An architectural study, subject, the Picture Gallery and Mausoleum of the late Sir Francis Bourgeois, at Dulwich' (A. Graves, The Royal Academy of Arts: a complete dictionary of contributors and their work, from its foundation in 1769 to 1904, 1970, p. 202)
From 1835 the drawing has been displayed in the North Drawing Room of 13 Lincoln's Inn Fields (inside plane on south wall). Some of these views offer the only record of the appearance of the building when it was first opened to the public. The title refers to the criticism of Reverend T. F. Dibdin; 'say what you please, and you cannot say anything so delightfully monstrous as is the exterior in question' and 'a maeso-gothic, semi-arabic, moro-spanish, an anglico-norman - a 'what you will' production!' (The Museum, volume 1, London, 1822).
Soane published in many forms the building he had wanted, in comparison to that executed, and this can be seen in the comparison views in the top left, centre and bottom right of this composite drawing. Soane was restricted in his design by funds and not by a lack of imagination and he wanted to ensure that his ideal schemes were recognised.
The drawings in the top left and centre show the more elaborate designs for the Gallery. The view in the top left shows the previous design to have a projecting two-storey entrance porch on the east to mirror the structure of the Mausoleum on the west and an open arcade. The top central drawing, in contrast, shows the east front as executed. In this view the entrance is just a door within a recessed arch and the arcade is in a much reduced style. The central bottom drawing shows the west front as executed. It reveals the round-topped sash windows finally chosen for the almshouses. Bottom right is the plan of the Gallery as a central feature within the proposed quadrangle. However the porch, the arcade on the east and the south range were never built. Bottom right is an enlarged plan of the Gallery, as if viewed from Gallery Road. The interior views of the Gallery and Mausoleum are very important for revealing the original internal structure. The centre left shows the five-bay enfilade of the Gallery, the red walls, the green oil-cloth floor, the octagonal skylights and the steam heaters in the centre of the rooms. However the initial colour of the gallery walls was burnt ochre and it was not until 1829 that Soane had them repainted red at his own expense. The centre right shows the cupola of the Mausoleum antechamber with Greek Doric columns leading to the top-lit burial chamber with the sarcophagi.
There is some uncertainty about the date of this drawing as there is no date inscribed on it. It is possible that it was executed in 1811 judging by the inscription on the frame. The bottom left plan corresponds to plans drawn following the meeting on 15 November 1811 agreeing to move the Mausoleum to the west front (see SM 65/4/49) so it could have been painted in late 1811. However the inscription on the frame was probably added at a later date, and actually refers to the fact that Soane began work at Dulwich College in 1811. The painting is a collaboration of ideal designs and designs as built so it is more likely that it was executed once building work was complete in 1813. Or perhaps it was painted during construction as the titles often refer to the 'present unfinished state'. It appears that this painting was exhibited at the Royal Academy in 1823, which suggests it was actually painted at an even later date. It is possible that Soane re-used an existing drawing to exhibit at the Royal Academy. However the painting could have been wholey inspired by the criticisms of Reverend T. F. Dibdin who made his statement in The Museum a journal which was only published 1822-1824. As he is referred to in the title of the painting this would corroborate the idea that it was painted in 1822-1823.
An enlarged copy of the central drawing can be found at the Dulwich Picture Gallery (DPG G44). An enlarged copy of the top left drawing can be found at the Victoria and Albert Museum (V&A 3307.108). Both of these paintings are undated and in the hand of Gandy.
From 1835 the drawing has been displayed in the North Drawing Room of 13 Lincoln's Inn Fields (inside plane on south wall). Some of these views offer the only record of the appearance of the building when it was first opened to the public. The title refers to the criticism of Reverend T. F. Dibdin; 'say what you please, and you cannot say anything so delightfully monstrous as is the exterior in question' and 'a maeso-gothic, semi-arabic, moro-spanish, an anglico-norman - a 'what you will' production!' (The Museum, volume 1, London, 1822).
Soane published in many forms the building he had wanted, in comparison to that executed, and this can be seen in the comparison views in the top left, centre and bottom right of this composite drawing. Soane was restricted in his design by funds and not by a lack of imagination and he wanted to ensure that his ideal schemes were recognised.
The drawings in the top left and centre show the more elaborate designs for the Gallery. The view in the top left shows the previous design to have a projecting two-storey entrance porch on the east to mirror the structure of the Mausoleum on the west and an open arcade. The top central drawing, in contrast, shows the east front as executed. In this view the entrance is just a door within a recessed arch and the arcade is in a much reduced style. The central bottom drawing shows the west front as executed. It reveals the round-topped sash windows finally chosen for the almshouses. Bottom right is the plan of the Gallery as a central feature within the proposed quadrangle. However the porch, the arcade on the east and the south range were never built. Bottom right is an enlarged plan of the Gallery, as if viewed from Gallery Road. The interior views of the Gallery and Mausoleum are very important for revealing the original internal structure. The centre left shows the five-bay enfilade of the Gallery, the red walls, the green oil-cloth floor, the octagonal skylights and the steam heaters in the centre of the rooms. However the initial colour of the gallery walls was burnt ochre and it was not until 1829 that Soane had them repainted red at his own expense. The centre right shows the cupola of the Mausoleum antechamber with Greek Doric columns leading to the top-lit burial chamber with the sarcophagi.
There is some uncertainty about the date of this drawing as there is no date inscribed on it. It is possible that it was executed in 1811 judging by the inscription on the frame. The bottom left plan corresponds to plans drawn following the meeting on 15 November 1811 agreeing to move the Mausoleum to the west front (see SM 65/4/49) so it could have been painted in late 1811. However the inscription on the frame was probably added at a later date, and actually refers to the fact that Soane began work at Dulwich College in 1811. The painting is a collaboration of ideal designs and designs as built so it is more likely that it was executed once building work was complete in 1813. Or perhaps it was painted during construction as the titles often refer to the 'present unfinished state'. It appears that this painting was exhibited at the Royal Academy in 1823, which suggests it was actually painted at an even later date. It is possible that Soane re-used an existing drawing to exhibit at the Royal Academy. However the painting could have been wholey inspired by the criticisms of Reverend T. F. Dibdin who made his statement in The Museum a journal which was only published 1822-1824. As he is referred to in the title of the painting this would corroborate the idea that it was painted in 1822-1823.
An enlarged copy of the central drawing can be found at the Dulwich Picture Gallery (DPG G44). An enlarged copy of the top left drawing can be found at the Victoria and Albert Museum (V&A 3307.108). Both of these paintings are undated and in the hand of Gandy.
Literature
A. Ballantyne, 'First principles and ancient errors: Soane at Dulwich', Journal of the Society of Architectural Historians of Great Britain, 37, 1994, pp. 98 & 106
C. Davies, 'Masters of building: the first independent purpose-built picture gallery: Dulwich Picture Gallery', Architect's Journal, April 1984, p. 56
F. Nevola, Soane's favourite subject: the story of Dulwich Picture Gallery, 2000, pp. 117 & 194-195
M. Richardson & M. Stevens (ed.), John Soane architect: master of space and light, Royal Academy of Arts, 1999, pp. 184-185
C. Davies, 'Masters of building: the first independent purpose-built picture gallery: Dulwich Picture Gallery', Architect's Journal, April 1984, p. 56
F. Nevola, Soane's favourite subject: the story of Dulwich Picture Gallery, 2000, pp. 117 & 194-195
M. Richardson & M. Stevens (ed.), John Soane architect: master of space and light, Royal Academy of Arts, 1999, pp. 184-185
Level
Drawing
Digitisation of the Drawings Collection has been made possible through the generosity of the Leon Levy Foundation
If you have any further information about this object, please contact us: drawings@soane.org.uk